Bringing You Joy, Sweetness, Deliciousness & Memories ...

Handmade from Scratch

New York Style Black and White Cookies

New York style cake-like cookies with half chocolate – half vanilla iced tops and just a hint of citrus have been popular since the early 20th century. Known as Black and White cookies (or “half-moons” as Hemstrought’s Bakery in NY originally called them), these filling delights have been a personal favorite of Nana’s Old Fashioned Treats’ owner since childhood. The full sized treats (approx 5″) are sold individually with a 3 treat minimum on a pre-order basis year round. Order yours today! They are also available as minis (approx 2.5″) sold in 2 treat increments (with a minimum half dozen order).

Sold individually priced with a 3 Cookie Minimum Order Requirement – Pickup/Local Delivery or California Shipping

$3.00

Available on backorder

(1 customer review)

Full Description

New York style cake-like cookies with half chocolate – half vanilla iced tops and just a hint of citrus have been popular since the early 20th century. Known as Black and White cookies (or “half-moons” as Hemstrought’s Bakery in NY originally called them), these filling delights have been a personal favorite of Nana’s Old Fashioned Treats’ owner since childhood. The full sized treats (approx 5″) are sold individually with a 3 treat minimum on a pre-order basis year round. Order yours today! They are also available as minis (approx 2.5″) sold in 2 treat increments (with a minimum half dozen order).

Sold individually priced with a 3 Cookie Minimum Order Requirement – ickup/Local Delivery or California Shipping

Packaged Individually to Maintain Freshness!
Individually packaged gift favor or tray Pre-Orders are also available for weddings, corporate events and large parties.

Contact us at yum@nanastreats.com for more information.

Made in a Permitted Home Kitchen in Riverside County, California.

Ingredients

Ingredients: COOKIE: Enriched Bleached Flour (bleached wheat flour, niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid, malted barley flour), Unsalted Butter (pasteurized cream, natural flavors), Whole Milk – Pasteurized (Milk, Ascorbic Acid (Vitamin C) And Vitamin D3), cornstarch, lemon juice, sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, baking powder, salt; ICING: Confectioners Sugar (cane sugar, cornstarch), unsweetened cocoa, Semisweet Chocolate Chips (sugar, chocolate, cocoa butter, milkfat, soy lecithin, natural flavors, Light Corn Syrup (corn syrup, salt, vanilla extract), Shortening – Butter Flavored (soybean oil, fully hydrogenated palm oil, palm oil, mono and diglycerides, TBHQ and citric acid (antioxidants), natural and artificial flavor, beta-carotene (pro vitamin A)), water, vanilla extract, salt.

Contains

Contains: Wheat, milk, eggs, soy

While Nana’s Old Fashioned Treats has some products that do not contain specific allergens and does indicate when allergens are present in the ingredient labels, our baked goods, candies, fudge & dipped dried fruits are made from scratch in an environment where wheat, milk, peanuts, tree nuts, eggs and soy may be present. As such, we cannot guarantee those with allergies to these ingredients will not have reactions to our products. Please purchase/consume responsibly.

Treat Care

Treat Care: Although our customers tend to quickly enjoy our treats, as long as you keep them in an airtight container (like the reusable tin they were packaged in), they will maintain their fresh taste up to 2 months in the freezer or up to 3 days at room temperature.

If you do freeze our treats until a craving hits or you need them for entertaining, it is best to take out the portion you want to consume or share, then let them come to room temperature for an hour or two before enjoying them. (Exception: Our Crisp Rice Cereal Marshmallow Treats only need to be thawed 15 minutes prior to enjoyment.)

Aside from our caramels, candy, fudge and dipped dried fruits, we do not recommend refrigerating our treats as that can lead to hard, dried out cookies rather than the high taste standards associated with Nana’s Old Fashioned Treats.

1 review for New York Style Black and White Cookies

  1. David Teincuff (verified owner)

    While these were good and better than most we have had, I think we are used to this type of cookie being larger in size and having more of a distinct difference between the chocolate side of the cookie and non-chocolate portion.

    They were delicious but we did find it hard to remove them from the individual wrappers that they came in.

    None the less, we would order them again over Purim.

    • Wendy (store manager)

      We have high standards at Nana’s Old Fashioned Treats and want to ensure our products and service are above and beyond so we went back to our recipe treasure trove, worked in our test kitchen, and updated our NY style black and white cookies. We agree that our prior recipe didn’t have enough distinction between the two icing flavors so our white side is now a truer vanilla flavor and our black side now has double the chocolate flavor. We also updated the size of these beloved treats. They can be purchased as individual large bakery size (approx. 5″) with a 6 count minimum, or by the dozen as mini size (approx 2.5″) cookies. For the trifecta of updates, our packaging has been redone to make it easier to enjoy these cakey delights.

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

New York Style Black and White Cookies

SKU Cook_blk_wht Categories , , , Tags ,

You may also like…